Apprenticeships Toolkit resources

Apprenticeships

Good-quality apprenticeships - delivered to those who are well-equipped to pursue them - can have a positive effect on employment, especially for young people from marginalised backgrounds.

Last updated: 26 August 2026
Compare outcomes for...
ImpactAn assessment of the likely median level of intervention's impact on outcomes
StrengthAn assessment of the degree of confidence that can be placed in the findings, in the context that all studies included in the toolkit are high-quality, peer-reviewed impact studies.
Education The headline measure for education is completing a 'school leaving' qualification by 24 months after the intervention starts. This corresponds broadly to passing GCSEs in England, or to Level 2 attainment, which is associated with lower risk of becoming NEET.
score icon Unknown impact
ImpactAn assessment of the likely median level of intervention's impact on outcomes
score icon Insufficient
StrengthAn assessment of the degree of confidence that can be placed in the findings, in the context that all studies included in the toolkit are high-quality, peer-reviewed impact studies.
Employment The headline measure for employment is whether a young person has been employed at any point in the 12-24 months after an intervention starts. Every young person has the right to earn, learn and thrive.
score iconscore iconscore icon High positive impact
ImpactAn assessment of the likely median level of intervention's impact on outcomes
score iconscore iconscore icon Emerging
StrengthAn assessment of the degree of confidence that can be placed in the findings, in the context that all studies included in the toolkit are high-quality, peer-reviewed impact studies.
Training The headline measure for training is whether a young person has engaged with Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) by 24 months after an intervention starts, which can support the development of workforce skills and increase long-term earning and employment prospects. This is a composite of several outcome metrics.
score icon Unknown impact
ImpactAn assessment of the likely median level of intervention's impact on outcomes
score icon Insufficient
StrengthAn assessment of the degree of confidence that can be placed in the findings, in the context that all studies included in the toolkit are high-quality, peer-reviewed impact studies.
Cost

We use a cost-description approach to help you estimate the relative indicative costs of delivering an intervention effectively. The more intense, complex or specific the provision needs, the higher the expected associated cost. These may vary considerably depending on programme duration, location, setting, and scale. Learn more in about the toolkit.

score iconscore iconscore icon High - likely to require intense, complex and specific resource needs for effective delivery
young person iconyoung person iconyoung person iconyoung person iconyoung person iconyoung person iconyoung person iconyoung person iconyoung person iconyoung person icon
10 more young people in work per 100 The percentage point change shows the "additional" benefit a component or programme provides compared to what would likely happen anyway ('business as usual'). This helps you identify which components provide the most significant boost to your existing services. The highest impact on employment presented in the Toolkit is a 10 percentage point increase, the equivalent of 10 in 100 additional young people. Learn more in 'about the toolkit'.

For every 100 young people who are NEET and take part in an apprenticeship as a targeted youth employment intervention, around 10 additional young people are in employment 12 to 24 months later compared to similar young people who did not take part. This intervention could increase recent employment by around 10 percentage points.

Key findings

Headline insights about this component based on current high-quality evidence

Positive

Improves employment outcomes

Good quality apprenticeships - delivered to those who are well-equipped to pursue them - can have a positive effect on employment, especially for young people from marginalised backgrounds.

Limitations

About the evidence

The evidence presented is based on earlier commissioned analysis which focused solely on employment outcomes. Education and training outcomes are unknown. This is different to the underlying analysis that informs other Youth Employment Toolkit entries.

Apprenticeships were not included as an Active Labour Market Programme in the most recent component network meta analysis that underpins the rest of the Toolkit.

The evidence presented for apprenticeships is based on earlier commissioned analysis, originally published as part of the first edition of the Youth Employment Toolkit. The research used a different methodology and only synthesised evidence for employment as an outcome.

Explore a summary of the previous research and learn more About the Toolkit.

Read moreRead less

What are apprenticeships?

Apprenticeships are vocational programmes that combine paid employment, practical training and study to build skills for a chosen industry.

Typically apprenticeships

  • focus on the development of skills required for a specific occupation or industry
  • provide paid work and on-the-job training with an employer
  • provide off-the-job training through an accredited learning provider such as a college, university, or independent training provider
  • may lead to a recognised qualification
  • can take from eight months to six years to complete, depending on the type and level of the apprenticeship

In England, apprenticeships are offered at levels from 2 to 7. Level 2 is equivalent to five GCSE passes, and Level 7 is equivalent to postgraduate study.

Who are apprenticeships for?

Read more about Who are apprenticeships for?

People aged 16 and over who are not in full-time education.

While people of all ages can become apprentices, the Youth Employment Toolkit specifically includes data on young apprentices.

Young people may enter apprenticeships for different reasons; they may want an entry-level role in a particular job or sector, an opportunity to upskill in an existing job, or a study pathway when they have left compulsory education.

Learn more about who can become an apprentice.

Who can offer apprenticeships?

Read more about Who can offer apprenticeships?

Companies of all sizes, from large corporations to small businesses, in all sectors including public and private.

How are apprenticeships funded?

Read more about How are apprenticeships funded?

Apprenticeship wages and funding systems vary between national and international contexts, as well as by sector, level and geographical location.

In England, employers can get a government subsidy for apprentices.

More info on funding in England

What are the delivery settings?

Read more about What are the delivery settings?
  • Workplaces of participating employers
  • College, university, or independent training provider in-person or virtual

Benefits for apprentices

By providing workplace experience and supporting the development of specific and more generalised skills, apprenticeship programmes are likely to increase a young person’s:

  • job readiness
  • suitability for a job related to the apprenticeship
  • chances of progressing to employment within the same organisation
  • continued development and learning

Benefits for employers

Apprenticeships enable employers to build a skilled and loyal workforce, tailoring training to their business needs while assessing talent for future roles.

They also support employers’ diversity and social responsibility commitments, while strengthening their reputation as an employer of choice.

Evidence shows apprenticeships:

  • boost productivity
  • improve staff retention
  • reduce recruitment costs
  • help address skills shortages

The cost rating for apprenticeships is highHigh - likely to require intense, complex and specific resource needs for effective deliveryhigh

Calculations are based on insights from available high-quality studies on the complexity of delivery requirements and estimated associated costs.

outreach iconOutreach and recruitment activity

Tailored and varied with associated staffing, materials, scheduling and administrative costs

clock iconDelivery duration

Long-term, usually 12 months or more

partners iconDelivery partners

Multiple providers including employers, training providers and potential intermediaries that need to co-ordinate in partnership, supported by programme planning and management, requiring additional admin resource

expertise iconDelivery expertise

Substantial, specialist and varied, including tutoring and curriculum design, specific curricula and assessment, learner support, and analysis of local labour market intelligence

wages iconWages, financial assistance or incentives

Apprenticeship wages, line manager wages, programme administration and management staff, specialist trainers

settings iconDelivery settings

Varied, integrated into existing workplaces of participating employers and college, university, or independent training provider in-person or virtual

outreach icon Outreach and recruitment activity

Tailored and varied with associated staffing, materials, scheduling and administrative costs

clock icon Delivery duration

Long-term, usually 12 months or more

partners icon Delivery partners

Multiple providers including employers, training providers and potential intermediaries that need to co-ordinate in partnership, supported by programme planning and management, requiring additional admin resource

expertise icon Delivery expertise

Substantial, specialist and varied, including tutoring and curriculum design, specific curricula and assessment, learner support, and analysis of local labour market intelligence

wages icon Wages, financial assistance or incentives

Apprenticeship wages, line manager wages, programme administration and management staff, specialist trainers

settings icon Delivery settings

Varied, integrated into existing workplaces of participating employers and college, university, or independent training provider in-person or virtual

Considerations for decision makers

Based on existing evidence, we’ve identified some common features that support the commissioning, design and delivery of effective apprenticeships:

01

Ensure outreach and awareness activities are effective and targeted to reach those most likely to benefit

Read more about Ensure outreach and awareness activities are effective and targeted to reach those most likely to benefit

Design, fund and deliver outreach and recruitment activities that raise young people’s awareness of apprenticeships, with targeted initiatives to reach under-represented group who are most likely to benefit.

This might include:

  • Young people who have been out of work and/or learning for longer periods.
  • Young people without Level 2 qualifications.
  • Young people whose life experiences put them at higher risk of marginalisation in the labour market, for example those with experience of the care system and/or with SEN.

Discover more about risk factors associated with being NEET.

Also consider how best to identify and engage the most suitable partners and employers for a programme. Engagement should be timely and clear, in ways that raise awareness and facilitate recruitment, enrolment, and sustained engagement.

Effective programmes may use direct community outreach activities for engaging under-served groups, alongside up-to-date local and administrative data, working with public employment services, or advertising vacancies along with eligibility criteria.

02

Build-in preparatory learning to support access and completion

Read more about Build-in preparatory learning to support access and completion

Establish effective pre-programme learning and orientation activities to bolster access to and completion of apprenticeships by

  • building realistic expectations
  • changing misconceptions
  • addressing gaps in skills and knowledge, particularly in Maths and English

Explore the Learning and Work Institute’s guidance for designing and delivering pre-apprenticeships and developing skills.

Employers and providers can use the Skills Builder Universal Framework for identifying and addressing gaps.

03

Tailor and structure programmes well to maintain engagement

Read more about Tailor and structure programmes well to maintain engagement

Design, fund and deliver programmes that:

  • are quality assured by appropriate methods where relevant
  • support young people to develop a range of theoretical, practical, transferrable and interpersonal skills
  • help learners maintain motivation and understand their professional and personal development
  • prioritise tailored support for participants, accounting for the complexity and diversity of individuals’ needs, which may include provision of equipment or adapted materials, or referrals to additional services
  • include pastoral, wellbeing and specialist support, particularly for apprentices with additional needs or who face additional barriers to the labour market
  • monitor and support tutor and manager capacity to reduce administrative and emotional burden, which may include training

Effective programmes may utilise personal advisors or co-designed action plans that align with participants’ goals, aspirations and circumstances. These are most effective when used consistently.

Providers of apprenticeships can use the Learning and Work Institute’s guidance for more info on how to design and deliver programmes that improve apprentices’ experience and engagement.

04

Take a joined-up, collaborative approach

Read more about Take a joined-up, collaborative approach

A strong relationship at all stages between policymakers, learning providers, employers, community organisations and local skills delivery organisations including Mayoral Strategic Authorities and Local Skills Improvement Plan areas supports effective apprenticeship implementation.

This can be facilitated by designated relationship managers in each organisation, clarity on responsibility and roles, and regular opportunities for staff training and good practice sharing.

Read the Institute of Public Policy Research’s report on the role of intermediaries in building partnerships for apprenticeships and increasing provision.

05

Recognise local economic priorities

Read more about Recognise local economic priorities

Match apprenticeship provision to opportunities in the local labour market and the skills needs of employers.

This can be supported by effective involvement and support in planning stages, and flexibility within national or regional frameworks to meet the needs of specific groups of learners, sectors, and employers.

06

Encourage systematic monitoring and evaluation to help build and strengthen the evidence base

Read more about Encourage systematic monitoring and evaluation to help build and strengthen the evidence base

Support providers and delivery organisations to accurately and systematically capture and communicate data and milestones and track programme outcomes. This may include structured and standardised tracking forms, or developing realistic programme-specific performance frameworks.

For funders and commissioners – ensure recorded data, reporting and assessment captures a full range of appropriate and relevant youth employment and related outcomes to help rich understanding to ensure rich picture of what programmes do.

Encouraging reporting commonly recognised metrics allows evaluation to be easily comparable and included in the growing evidence base.

07

Prioritise iterative design and implementation strategies 

Read more about Prioritise iterative design and implementation strategies 

Design, fund and deliver apprenticeships that can incorporate staff and young people’s insights and feedback to better respond to needs and improve service delivery, performance and outcomes.

Relevant and strategic adjustments may include changing the intensity, duration of or type of elements, or adapting eligibility criteria or services to fit the needs of young people in the local area.

About the evidence

What’s included in the analysis?

Read more about What’s included in the analysis?
Included studies2
Location(s)USA (Care should be taken when translating policy and practice to the UK context)
OutcomeLikelihood of entering employment
Comparator'Services as usual' / Business as usual

The Youth Employment Toolkit brings together evidence from robust studies in high-income countries that:

  1. measured the intervention’s impact against what would have happened without it
  2. defined apprenticeship programmes as a targeted intervention to support youth employment outcomes

Find details of individual studies of evaluations of apprenticeships, as well as other systematic reviews of youth employment evaluations, in the Youth Employment Evidence and Gap Map.

The evidence presented for apprenticeships is based on earlier commissioned analysis, originally published as part of the first edition of the Youth Employment Toolkit. The research used a different methodology and only synthesised evidence for employment as an outcome. Explore the previous research.

Please note this is different to the underlying analysis that informs other Youth Employment Toolkit entries.

The evidence strength ratings for apprenticeships reflect the number of studies included in the meta-analysis. Studies were scored on reported design, sample size, approach to attrition, and definitions of interventions and outcome measures. More detail can be found in the associated technical guide.

As the evidence presented here is based on earlier commissioned analysis, there is no insight available on education or training outcomes.

Implications for evaluators and commissioners

Read more about Implications for evaluators and commissioners

Very few studies evaluate the impact of apprenticeships, particularly as a targeted intervention to support marginalised young people into work, highlighting the need for further evaluations.